Archive/Fossil/Can Plants Feel? What Science Reveals
Fossil Excavation · Fossil

Can Plants Feel? What Science Reveals

GEO-394READER FAVORITEStratigraphyFossil Excavation
Can Plants Feel? What Science Reveals
10 cm
click any image to enlarge
OrganismGastropod
EraTertiary
Age50 Ma
RegionDeccan Traps
SpecimenGEO-394
● 10 min read·Field report from Deccan Traps

Field report

They just might. The real question is how sophisticated their responses truly are.

David Kuchta, Ph.D. has spent a decade working in gardens and reading widely on environmental history and the shifting energy landscape. An environmental activist since the 1970s, he is also a historian, author, gardener, and educator.

JokoHarismoyo / Getty Images

Did you know?

The Earth's inner core is a solid ball of iron-nickel alloy about 1,220 km in radius, with a temperature comparable to the surface of the Sun.

A key distinction between plants and animals lies in how they respond to stimuli. Humans possess brains, where stimuli are interpreted and responses crafted. What we call "emotional" responses are really layered reactions to layered social cues.

Plants lack a central nervous system, yet they can still take in information from their surroundings and react to it. While plants don't experience "feelings" the way humans do, they often retain memories of stimuli and relay messages to neighboring plants about them.

How Plant and Animal Responses Differ

Animals possess neurons that carry sensory signals to a central nervous system (the brain). In humans, once your brain decides those signals are negative and threatening, it dispatches a message back to where the pain originated, prompting you to react and avoid further harm.

Animals like us rely on memory to steer clear of future harm. Curiously, the memory of a past injury doesn't itself trigger a fresh flood of adrenaline when the recollection surfaces.

Lacking a central nervous system, plants don't process sensations the way animals do. Still, they do react to unpleasant or damaging stimuli. Brush the leaves of the aptly named sensitive plant, Mimosa pudica, and it will fold them shut. Prune a shrub, and the shrub will seal the wound with a callous and likely push out new growth just below the cut.

Plants hold on to memories of these events—not in a centralized brain, but distributed throughout the organism, close to where the memory is needed. This is more than a simple biophysical reflex. Touch the leaves of a sensitive plant repeatedly, and it will eventually stop folding them. It has learned that the sensation poses no threat, and it retains that knowledge for up to 40 days.1

Similarly, perennial flowering plants recall when to resume growth in spring. Blooming before pollinators have emerged from winter would be wasted effort. Blooming while it's still too cold risks injury or even death. So many plants produce proteins that let them track how many days have passed since they were last exposed to cold, only breaking dormancy when conditions seem safe.2

Communication Between Species

oddonatta / Getty Images

Among the most significant and widespread interspecies partnerships on Earth is the mycorrhizal bond between fungi and plant roots—a relationship found in roughly 90% of plant species.3

Through these networks, plants exchange messages with fungi and neighboring plants, transferring nutrients and broadcasting stress signals.4 Plants share essential elements like nitrogen, carbon, and phosphorus via fungal pathways.5 Aloe, tomatoes, and other species also alert one another with electrical signals—the plant equivalent of electronic messaging—to spur growth, accelerate wound healing, and more. This vast subterranean network puts the internet to shame.6

Plants also relay stress chemically through their leaves. When a herbivore nibbles a sagebrush plant or an acacia tree, the plant releases toxins not only to repel the nibbler but to warn nearby plants, which then begin producing their own defensive toxins.7

Plants Tune In to Sound

Like many animals, certain plants also communicate with sound. Sound is simply vibration in air, something plant cells can evolve to generate and plant tissues to detect.

Recent research into plant communication shows that some species emit high-frequency sound waves.8 Tomato and tobacco plants, for instance, produce sounds during drought or when their leaves are cut.9

Plants can also be attentive listeners. Pea plants send their roots toward the sound of flowing water—even when the sound is recorded and no water is actually present.10 And primrose flowers produce sweeter nectar when exposed to the sound (natural or artificial) of buzzing bees.11

The bulk of a plant's life unfolds underground. This is where plants do their "thinking," in a decentralized web of sensory and memory cells—a nervous system that may contain upward of a trillion cells, roughly on par with the human brain.12 Yet humans tend to prize plants mainly for their reproductive organs—their flowers, fruits, and seeds—rather than the parts that think and feel. Like us, plants rely on both to survive.

Common Questions

Consciousness arises from intricate neural interactions within a central nervous system—which plants lack. But don't conflate memory with conscious thought. Even in humans, memory need not be conscious. Our memory T-cells learn to recognize and fight off infectious organisms without any conscious input from us. Vaccinations wouldn't work if our cells lacked a memory function. In both plants and humans, memory can unfold at the cellular level, entirely independent of consciousness.

Plants don't possess a limbic system—the part of the human brain that generates emotions and memories from sensory experience—so they don't experience complex emotions like happiness or sadness. When you mow the lawn, the grass doesn't get angry with you, but it does release that familiar "cut grass" smell, a volatile compound given off when grass is attacked by herbivores. The compound lures carnivores that then attack the herbivores.13 So the grass doesn't get mad; it gets even.

Mancuso, Stefano.The Revolutionary Genius of Plants: A New Understanding of Plant Intelligence and Behavior. New York: Atria Books, 2018, 18.

Fu-Yu Hung, et al. “ WRKY63 transcriptional activation ofCOOLAIRandCOLDAIRregulates vernalization-induced flowering.”Plant Physiologykiac295 (June 16 2022). https://doi.org/10.1093/plphys/kiac295.

Nguyen, Nhu H. et al. “FUNGuild: An open annotation tool for parsing fungal community datasets by ecological guild”Fungal Ecology29 (2016), 241–248. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.funeco.2015.06.006.

Boyno, Gökhan, and Semra Demir. “Plant‑mycorrhiza communication and mycorrhizae in inter‑plant communication.”Symbiosis86 (2022), 155–168. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13199-022-00837-0.

Song, Yuan Yuan, et al. “Hijacking common mycorrhizal networks for herbivore-induced defence signal transfer between tomato plants.”Scientific Reports4:3915 (January 31, 2014) 1–9. DOI: 10.1038/srep03915.

Volkov, Alexander G., and Yuri B. Shtessel. “Electrotonic signal transduction betweenAloe veraplants using underground pathways in soil: Experimental and analytical study.”Biophysics4:4 (17 October 2017), 576–595. DOI: 10.3934/biophy.2017.4.576; Volkov, Alexander G., and Yuri B. Shtessel. “Electrical signal propagation within and between tomato plants.”Bioelectrochemistry124 (2018) 195–205. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bioelechem.2018.08.001.

Karban, Richard, Patrick Grof-Tisza, and Charline Couchoux. “Consistent individual variation in plant communication: do plants have personalities?”Oecologia199 (2022),129–137. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00442-022-05173-0; Bonato, Bianca, et al. “Cracking the code: a comparative approach to plant communication.”Communicative & Integrative Biology, 14:1 (2021), 176–185, doi: : 10.1080/19420889.2021.1956719; Wohlleben, Peter.The Hidden Life of Trees: What They Feel, How They Communicate. Berkeley, CA: Greystone Books, 2015, 15.

Bhandawat, Abhishek, and Kuldip Jayaswall. “Biological relevance of sound in plants.”Environmental and Experimental Botany200 (August 2022), 104919. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envexpbot.2022.104919.

Khait, I., et al. “Plants emit Plants airborne sounds under stress.”BioRxiv507590 (December 2019), doi: https://doi.org/10.1101/507590.

Gagliano, Monica, et al. “Tuned in: plant roots use sound to locate water.”Oecologia184 (2017), 151–160. DOI 10.1007/s00442-017-3862-z.

Veits, Marine, et al. “Flowers respond to pollinator sound within minutes by increasing nectar sugar concentration.”Ecology Letters22 (2019), 1483–1492. di: 10.1111/ele.13331.

Mancuso, op, cit., 56.

Allmann, Silke, and Ian T. Baldwin. “Insects Betray Themselves in Nature to Predators by Rapid Isomerization of Green Leaf Volatiles”Science329:5995 (27 August 2010), 1075–1078. doi: 10.1126/science.1191634.

References & Sources

  • Primary source: https://www.treehugger.com/do-plants-have-feelings-science-explainer-5546944
  • Regional reference: Deccan Traps geological survey.
  • Cross-reference: Fossil Excavation archive, specimen GEO-394.

Continue the Fieldwork

  • Visit a local geological museum and examine their mineral collection.
  • Take a field notebook on your next hike and sketch the rock formations you see.
  • Support organizations that protect fossil heritage sites from looting.

Specimen bookmarked for your next dig.